1958 Piper Comanche
Single Engine Piston
Aircraft Details
Seller reportedAvionics & Equipment
IFRDescription
Beautiful vintage Comanche with excellent pedigree and numerous upgrades. This aircraft combines classic ramp appeal with strong mechanical fundamentals, featuring a Western Skyways Gold Seal engine overhaul, upgraded McCauley three-blade propeller, modern Garmin ADS-B transponder, and recent exhaust. The Comanche 250 is known for its impressive speed, efficiency, and range, a true traveling machine with solid performance and handling. Well cared for and nicely equipped, this one has the right blend of performance, modernization, and classic Piper craftsmanship.
Propeller
McCauley three-blade
Interior
Gray, Black & Red
Exterior
Juneau White w/ Lockhaven Yellow & Orange
Inspection
Annual Due: June 2026
Modifications / STCs
• Stabilator Aussie Horn (Tail AD Compliance)
• 3 Blade McCauley Prop
• LED Landing Lights
• 2023 Exhaust
• Western Skyways Engine Overhaul
• Polished Spinner
• Bogert Copper Wire Kit
• Bogert Battery Box
• Stall Light
• Custom Interior
• Pitot Heat
• Rotating Beacon & Nav Lights
• Cabin Heat
• Carbon Monoxide Detector
• Pilot Vent Window
• Vernier Prop & Mixture Controls
Description and equipment details provided by the seller. AeroGurus does not verify seller-provided information.
Price Comparison 1 active offer
| Source | Price | Location | Listed | Days on Market | Status | Action |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
NexGA Aircraft
globalair.com
|
$79,000
|
AR | Mar 13, 2026 | 2 days | Active | |
|
NexGA Aircraft, Inc. - William Byrd
trade-a-plane.com
|
$79,000
|
Greensboro (), NC | Mar 30, 2026 | 85 days | Active | |
|
NexGA Aircraft
controller.com
|
$79,000
|
Greensboro, NC | Mar 25, 2026 | 90 days | Active | |
|
NexGA Aircraft
controlleremea.co.uk
|
$79,102 *
GBP £59,705
|
Greensboro, NC | Apr 08, 2026 | 75 days | Active | |
|
NexGA Aircraft
aviationtrader.com.au
|
$81,435
|
Greensboro, North Carolina | Apr 06, 2026 | 77 days | Active |
* Converted to USD at daily European Central Bank (ECB) exchange rates
Estimate Monthly Payment
Piper Comanche loan calculator
AeroGurus Data & Analysis
Independent data from FAA, NTSB, and market analysis
About This Piper Comanche
This 1958 Piper Comanche (N5217P) is a 4-seat single engine piston with 6,440 hours on the airframe. There are currently 66 Comanche aircraft listed for sale with asking prices ranging from $39,746 to $339,000. This aircraft is priced below the market average at $79,000.
The Comanche cruises at 157 kts (291 km/h) with a range of 956 nm (1,771 km) — ideal for short hops and local flights. Service ceiling of 20,000 ft allows operation above most weather.
Operating costs: Fuel burn is 14 GPH (53 L/h), which at current Jet-A prices (~$5.50/gal) means approximately $77/hr in fuel alone.
NTSB records show 0 incidents for this airframe — a clean safety record.
Pre-Purchase Checklist
Piper Comanche — Model Specs
Model specificationStandard specs for this model. Actual aircraft may differ.
Estimated Cost of Ownership
AeroGurus estimatePIPER Comanche
AeroGurus estimates based on industry averages for the PIPER Comanche. Actual costs vary by location, usage, maintenance history, and configuration. Not a financial quote.
Ownership & Registration
FAA registration data pending for N5217P.
Location & Ownership
Title Status
No FAA title records
Available for US-registered aircraft only
Source: FAA Aircraft Registry, FAA Civil Aviation Registry (DocIndex). Title data may be delayed. Always verify with an aviation attorney before purchase.
Safety Record
NTSB safety data coming soon.
We'll check N5217P against the NTSB accident database.
